ASWB Outline Competency Series · TOTP Topic 3
Identifying and resolving ethical dilemmas
From the Ethical Principles and Responsibilities competency in the 2026 Bachelors, Masters, and Clinical exam outlines. Topic numbering follows TOTP’s study sequence; ASWB lists this topic as an applied knowledge statement.

Two answers can sound responsible. Your task is to identify which response fits the actual conflict. Ethical dilemmas on the ASWB exam become easier to analyze when you can name the competing duties, notice what is still unknown, and explain the consequences of a choice.
This lesson develops that reasoning through a worked example and two original practice items. Start with the situation, then use the principles to understand it.
What makes a situation an ethical dilemma?
An ethical dilemma involves competing professional obligations or values. Fulfilling one can place another at risk. Feeling uncertain is a clue to examine a situation, but uncertainty alone does not establish that two ethical duties conflict.
- A knowledge gap: you need to find out what a policy or requirement says.
- A personal disagreement: the client’s preference differs from yours.
- An ethical dilemma: two defensible professional responsibilities pull toward different actions.
The NASW Code of Ethics guides professional judgment without providing a fixed ranking that resolves every conflict. Relevant standards, law, context, and appropriate consultation all inform the decision.
A worked example: access and professional boundaries
Imagine a social worker in a small rural community. A new referral turns out to be someone who participates in the same volunteer organization. Another provider is available, but that provider has a long waiting list. The prospective client would prefer local services.
A quick answer might be “refer immediately” or “accept because help is needed.” Both skip important information. Here is how to develop the analysis:
- Name the tension: access to timely services versus potential boundary problems and conflicts of interest.
- Identify missing facts: how closely do they work together? Does either person supervise the other? Can confidentiality be protected in their shared setting?
- Consider realistic options: referral, a different service arrangement, or safeguards may have different consequences depending on those facts.
- Seek focused consultation: bring a specific question about the overlapping roles, rather than simply asking someone else to choose.
- Explain and document the reasoning: record the relevant facts, consultation, options considered, and basis for the plan.
This example is deliberately incomplete. Its lesson is to recognize what must be clarified before selecting a course of action. It does not mean every overlapping community contact prohibits services or that limited access makes every relationship acceptable.
Change one detail: suppose the social worker is also the person’s employer. How does that change the power relationship? Practicing with one changed fact helps you understand why context can change the answer.
Consultation is useful when it has a purpose
Compare “I will ask my supervisor” with “I will consult about the conflict between access and overlapping authority, after identifying the roles involved.” The second statement reveals the ethical problem. It also makes the consultation more productive.
For practice questions, avoid treating consultation as an automatic answer. If the stem already establishes an urgent action, a clear responsibility, or completed consultation, repeating that step may miss what the question asks. Read for the stage of the decision: identifying, clarifying, deciding, acting, or evaluating.
Use the stem to test your explanation
“The key is hidden in the STEM.” At TOTP, that means using the facts provided while bringing the professional knowledge needed to interpret them. It does not mean a keyword can replace knowledge.
After answering an item, complete these three sentences:
- “The competing responsibilities are ___ and ___.”
- “The detail that changes my decision is ___.”
- “The strongest distractor is less appropriate here because ___.”
If your explanation fits every question equally well, make it more specific. “Protect the client” is a goal. “Clarify the disclosure permission before responding to this request” identifies an action and its reason.
Common study questions
Does every difficult decision have one risk-free solution?
No. A defensible decision may still involve tradeoffs. Identify the responsibilities and consequences instead of searching for an option that promises to eliminate all uncertainty.
Should I add details from similar cases I have seen?
Use your knowledge, but separate it from assumptions. A case from your workplace may include facts that the practice item does not provide.
Two ethical-dilemma practice items
Choose before revealing the key. These original examples teach reasoning, not recalled exam content.
Practice item 1 · Recall
A social worker is reviewing situations that may require ethical decision making. Which situation BEST illustrates an ethical dilemma?
- The social worker needs to locate the agency’s current record-retention schedule.
- Protecting one professional obligation may compromise another relevant professional obligation.
- The client selects an appropriate service that the social worker would not personally choose.
Show key and rationale
Key: Protecting one professional obligation may compromise another relevant professional obligation.
Rationale: The key identifies a conflict between professional obligations. Locating a retention schedule is primarily an information task unless additional conflicting duties emerge. A client’s different preference may prompt self-reflection, but it does not by itself create an ethical conflict. The distinguishing feature is the competing responsibility, not the social worker’s discomfort.
Practice item 2 · Application
A community social worker is asked to help a neighborhood group seek a grant. The worker also sits on the committee that will recommend grant recipients. The committee’s conflict-of-interest policy has not yet been reviewed, and there is time before applications are due. What should the social worker do FIRST?
- Help draft the application while planning to abstain from the final vote.
- Decline all contact with the neighborhood group to eliminate any appearance of conflict.
- Clarify the competing roles and review the conflict-of-interest requirements before agreeing to assist.
- Ask the neighborhood group whether it is comfortable with the worker serving in both roles.
Show key and rationale
Key: Clarify the competing roles and review the conflict-of-interest requirements before agreeing to assist.
Rationale: The overlapping advisory and funding roles create the issue that must be examined before committing. Abstaining later may not address influence during the application or recommendation process. Declining all contact is premature before clarifying what boundaries are required. The group’s comfort does not resolve obligations to other applicants or the committee.
Turn understanding into exam confidence
Prepare to pass with a plan that fits your goals. Explore TOTP’s learning modules, tutoring options, and live study groups.
Explore Live Study Groups →Keep building your foundation: social work ethical responsibilities and confidentiality and context.
Sources and scope
- ASWB Examination Guidebook (August 2026): Bachelors, Masters, and Clinical outlines, Values and Ethics.
- NASW Code of Ethics: purpose, ethical principles, and relevant practice standards.
- NASW responsibilities to clients, including informed consent, self-determination, and competence.
Original TOTP teaching examples and practice items; not actual ASWB questions. Educational content does not replace applicable law, supervision, or consultation. TOTP is an independent preparation provider, not affiliated with or endorsed by ASWB.
